Theories

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 10/21/2024

Theory: On the blogpost on March 21, 2005, the sleepwalking during a sleepover with Janice, Abel, Katt, and Rami is suspicious...

Evidence Cited:

• Naomi's Blog

Name: A

Date Submitted: 07/09/2015

Theory: Two dates coincide: Naomi brings her phone to the police on Dec 6 2004, and she was last seen Dec 6 2006. Maybe those are connected?

Evidence Cited:

• Missing Poster
• Naomi's Blog

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 09/31/2014

Theory: Looking at the perspective that the CCTV footage screenshot was taken from .. this person looks kind of taller that 5'7. Maybe its just a similar outfit to Naomi or maybe thats the suspect? Like, if they took her clothes? Maybe that explains her phone being in the field nearby...

Evidence Cited:

• CCTV Footage
• Missing Poster

Name: S.H.

Date Submitted: 06/16/2013

Theory: It's really suspicious that the phone record shows the text messages all coming from the same number. And the police couldn't trace that? Or find out anything about the caller? I don't know who might have abducted her, but it must have been someone who had a connection with the police so that they wouldn't say anything or check that actual number.

Evidence Cited:

• SMS Transcript

Name: C

Date Submitted: 11/05/2013

Theory: Lowkey the text messages do seem automated, like they repeat in almost a pattern sometimes - its not an exact pattern but maybe the guy talking about the zip file has a point.

Evidence Cited:

• SMS Transcript
• Naomi's Blog

Name: Rob

Date Submitted: 12/22/2012

Theory: People are overlooking the zip file N downloaded on October 20, 2004 according to the blog. Like, security wasn't much of a thing back then, and you could easily find out what IP address a user had if you were talking with them; open ports and physical location information to easily follow. You could also basically gain full access to their PC if you did a file transfer with them. Even though she did check it with her brother, I doubt that following instructions over the phone to check for malware is the best way to ensure the desktop is safe.

Evidence Cited:

• Naomi's Blog.

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 04/04/2012

Theory: I feel like the forgetfulness is too insane, like as a healthy teen, how on earth are you losing these things so easily and so unexpededly...like idk it seems like maybe theres ssomething more to that. Like, as soon as she started working at wommaks, she started inexplicably losing things that were important to her? Maybe someone saw her there and became an obsessive stalker or something? she was interacting face to face with a lot of the community, who knows how many people pass through a store like that. The mitten: it was a packed, dark theature, before halloween, ANYONE could be in there. Maybe this guy was follwing her around in person too. Maybe he was close enough to cut her hair then? Same with the bracelet, it inexplicably disappeared. PLUS the fact that both of these missing objects were later FOUND out in the WOODS makes me suspicious.

Evidence Cited:

• Bracelet
• Mitten
• Envelope
• Naomi's Blog
• Wommak's Great American Food Store

Name: Jen

Date Submitted: 02/18/2012

Theory: Do ya'll noticce how Kat was telling Naomi to wait till the morning to tell her parents about the text messages???? IDK SEEEMS SUSPICIOUS TO ME...

Evidence Cited:

• Naomi's Blog

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 09/11/2010

Theory: People saying shes lonely r and wanted to run away are missing the point- Her MOM, her DAD, her THERAPIST were all saying she was doing better since the initiall harassment incidents, and she HERSELF said she felt happier because she made new friends.

Evidence Cited:

• Newspaper
• Naomi's Blog

Name: Angie L

Date Submitted: 08/10/2010

Theory: Honestly one of the unexpectedly chilling details for me was the sleepwalking she mentioned off hand in her entries (March 21, 2005), she said she had never slept walked before and she woke up in her driveway with chalk hearts drawn around her - AND it seems like they didn't even have chalk at her house. like wtf is that about? was the guy in her house this whole time?

Evidence Cited:

• Naomi's Blog

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 07/08/2010

Theory: The two caverns in the area make me wonder if maybe she could have found some opening to a cave and gotten stuck there. the mitten + bracelet were found closer to the caverns.

Evidence Cited:

• Bracelet
• Mitten
• Maps

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 06/30/2010

Theory: Do we know if the glove found in the woods was her original glove that naomi lost or the second pair she got from kat?

Evidence Cited:

• Bracelet
• Mitten
• Naomi's Blog

Name: me

Date Submitted: 05/23/2010

Theory: yo did anyone catch the queer subplot

Evidence Cited:

• Bracelet
• Naomi's Blog

Name: N/A

Date Submitted: 01/02/2010

Theory: Her phone being found without a bettery or memory card seems intentional to me. Maybe she just wanted to run away, she was really lonely at school

Evidence Cited:

• Phone
• Naomi's Blog